Confessions of A Fiduciary Advisor: Deconstructing the Emotional & Mental Roadblocks That Sabatoge Many Retirees' Ability To Make Sound Financial Decisions.
by Paul D. Spurlock, CRPC
As a fiduciary advisor, my job is to act in the best interests of my clients, offering sound financial advice and strategies that meet their long-term goals.
But over the years, I’ve learned that sometimes the hardest part of the job isn’t crafting the perfect plan or finding the right products—it’s helping retirees and pre-retirees overcome the emotional roadblocksthat prevent them from making sound financial decisions.
In fact, the most challenging obstacle I face isn’t finding a qualified fiduciary advisor—it’s helping the client act in their own best interest without second-guessing themselves into financial paralysis. Many retirees get stuck in an endless loop of conflicting advice, fear, and emotional biases, which ultimately derails their ability to make wise decisions that are aligned with their goals.
In this article, I’ll discuss some of the most common emotional roadblocks that prevent retirees from making optimal financial decisions, and offer strategies on how to overcome them for a more secure and stress-free retirement.
The Mental & Emotional Roadblocks to Sound Financial Decisions
1. Normalcy Bias: “It’s Always Been Fine, So It Must Be Fine Now”
Many people believe that because their current portfolio has worked for them in the past, it will continue to serve them well in the future. This belief is a form of normalcy bias, where people assume that the way things have always been will continue indefinitely.
For example, someone may have built their wealth using traditional strategies—like investing in stocks, bonds, or real estate—and assume these same strategies will keep working in retirement. However, as we enter an era of low interest rates, market volatility, and changing tax laws, relying on outdated strategies can be risky.
The Solution: The first step in overcoming normalcy bias is acknowledging that retirement is different from wealth accumulation. In retirement, the primary focus should be on income generation, principal preservation, and ensuring that funds last throughout your lifetime. It’s essential to periodically reassess your strategy, especially as you transition into retirement, to ensure it aligns with your current needs and future goals.
2. Fear of Making a Mistake: The Paralysis of Overthinking
One of the most powerful emotions that can derail sound financial decision-making is the fear of making a mistake. This fear can cause someone to freeze, unable to take action for fear that they might make the wrong choice. This is particularly true for those who have never navigated the complexities of retirement planning before.
The fear of making a mistake often leads to inaction, which is the worst possible scenario for someone trying to prepare for a secure future. Many clients I work with find themselves stuck in analysis paralysis, unable to commit to a strategy because they’re afraid of choosing the wrong one.
The Solution: As a fiduciary advisor, my role is not just to provide advice, but to also educate clients on their options. One of the best ways to overcome this fear is to take small, informed steps toward a solution. Instead of making drastic changes all at once, work with your advisor to create a plan that feels comfortable and manageable. Knowledge is power, and once clients are confident in the reasoning behind their decisions, they are far less likely to second-guess themselves.
3. Fear of Loss: “What If I Lose Money In A Bad Investment Choice?”
The fear of losing money is another powerful emotion that keeps retirees from acting in their best interests. Many people become so focused on avoiding losses that they make overly conservative choices, like keeping too much cash in savings or investing too heavily in low-yield bonds. While avoiding loss is understandable, it can be detrimental when it results in lower growth and inadequate retirement income.
I see this fear most often in clients who have experienced market crashes or losses in the past, which leaves them overly cautious and unwilling to take on any perceived risk, even though they may need to take on some level of risk to achieve their goals.
The Solution: It’s important to recognize that risk is inevitable in any investment strategy, but it can be managed. The key is to develop a diversified portfolio that includes investments tailored to your income needs, risk tolerance, and time horizon.
Annuities, for example, can provide guaranteed income and reduce risk by ensuring that you don’t outlive your assets. Working with an advisor to understand and balance risk is critical to overcoming this fear.
4. Fear of Missing Out (FOMO): “What if I’m Not Taking Advantage of the Latest Trend?”
The fear of missing out is a strong emotional pull that causes many retirees to chase the latest investment trends. Whether it’s the allure of hot stocks, cryptocurrencies, or the latest “market-moving” strategy, FOMO can lead to impulsive decisions that aren’t aligned with a person’s long-term goals.
Many retirees are exposed to well-meaning but flawed second opinions from friends, family, or online resources, pushing them to take more risk or switch strategies that don’t suit their needs. They might hear about someone else’s big gains and wonder, “What if I’m missing out on that opportunity?”
The Solution: It’s important to focus on a financial plan that is customized to your specific needs and goals—not someone else’s. Chasing trends can lead to poor decisions and unnecessary risks. Instead, work with a fiduciary advisor to develop a strategy that fits your retirement timeline and income requirements. A well-designed strategy will offer you peace of mind and reduce the need to chase after the latest trend.
5. Being a Creature of Habit: Resistance to Change
Change is hard, and many retirees find it difficult to adjust their approach when they’ve been used to doing things a certain way for years or even decades. Whether it’s relying on stocks or simply refusing to reallocate assets as their needs change, resistance to change is a natural reaction.
Many clients have spent their entire careers focused on growth through equity-based investments, and now that they’re in the income phase of life, they are reluctant to switch to products that are better suited for income, like annuities or bonds.
The Solution: The first step is to recognize the need for change. Just as you wouldn’t wear the same clothes throughout all stages of life, your investment strategy needs to evolve as well. Working with an advisor who understands both growth strategies and income-producing options will allow you to transition smoothly and confidently into retirement.
Overcoming Emotional Roadblocks: A Path Forward
As a fiduciary advisor, my role is not just about offering investment advice—it’s about helping clients navigate the emotional roadblocks that often get in the way of sound financial decision-making. It’s not enough to just have a good financial plan; clients need to have the confidence to execute that plan without constantly second-guessing themselves or letting fear dictate their choices.
Here are a few steps to help retirees overcome these roadblocks:
-
Work with a fiduciary advisor who will always act in your best interest and provide education to help you make confident decisions.
-
Create a written financial plan that is tailored to your goals, risk tolerance, and income needs.
-
Take small steps toward executing your plan, rather than trying to make sweeping changes all at once.
-
Focus on long-term goals and avoid getting distracted by short-term market trends or second opinions.
-
Build a diversified portfolio that provides both growth and security, and balance risk with the need for reliable income.
The key to overcoming emotional roadblocks is to embrace a thoughtful, disciplined approach to retirement planning.
When you do that, you can move forward with confidence, knowing that your financial future is in good hands.